10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food

Who does not want to have grilled food at home that reminds them of their favourite restaurant? But how can one have the best grilled food at home? The answer is simple – broiler pans! Broiler pans are multi-functional utensils that are almost essential in a kitchen. With an appearance that looks like a cookie tray but with a grate and grills, broiler pans cook your food evenly. The best broiler pans are known for using a lesser amount of oil and emit lesser heat as well. This makes it great for people who hate the flame and the heat in a kitchen during summers.

However, the market is packed with a diversified variety of these. Some are disposable, some are non-stick pans, and some vary in sizes as well. Therefore, to help you decide and pick one best broiler pan for your kitchen, this article is here to help! We will look at some in-depth details and descriptions of the 10 best and most popular broiler pans in the market. Whether you need a broiler pan to host big dinners, or you need one as a toaster, we have got you covered.

Overview table

Before looking into the pans in detail, let’s first take a quick look at the best features and their pros of the 10 best broiler pans. We want you to purchase the best broiler pan that meets all your needs perfectly. So here is why the following products are the best in their own way:

 

Editor choice 1 Frigidaire 5304442087
9.9
Frigidaire 5304442087
(Best durable broiler pan)

Its porcelain coating makes it resistant to corrosion and gives a clean finish. Say goodbye to old days of scrubbing and washing broiler pans after cooking your favourite meals!

9.9
2 Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan
9.8
Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan
(Best versatile broiler pan)

Cook all kinds of meat in no time by using this broiler pan by Granite Ware. Its carbon steel construction allows heat to evenly distribute and cook like a pro!

9.8
3 Disposable Aluminium Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan
9.7

Don’t have a large kitchen space to store a broiler pan? These disposable pans will solve this problem for you. This unit helps save a lot of cleaning and maintenance time.

9.7
4 Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
9.7
Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
(Best non-stick broiler pan)

The Wilton features a non-stick cooking surface. Use this pan to make sure that all your food is cooked perfectly without any mess for you to clean up later.

9.7
5 General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan and Rack
9.6

Have a huge party to host? Don’t have enough cook ware to manage the large quantities of food? Use this large-sized broiler pan for cooking the best meals in no time!

9.6
6 Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan
9.5

Made with steel, this pan is going to last in your kitchen for a long time. With a heavy-duty construction and an efficient design, evenly heat and cook all your food safely at high temperatures.

9.5
7 Range Kleen Broiler Pan
9.4
Range Kleen Broiler Pan
(Best large broiler pan for high temperatures)

Too tired to clean and scrub the pans after a fun party? This dishwasher-safe broiling pan is made for you! Easy to clean and low-maintenance, saving you lots of time and energy!

9.4
8 Norpro 273 Broil/Roast Pan Set
9.3
Norpro 273 Broil/Roast Pan Set
(Best broiler pan to cook for two)

Love to make quick meals for yourself? Or just trying to make healthier food choices? This is the perfectly-sized broiling pan for 1- or 2-people’s meal, which cooks healthier food in lesser time!

9.3
9 Nordic Ware 42210 Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler
9.1

If you plan on carrying a broiling plan with you on your next road trip to cook your favourite meals, this Nordic Ware broiler pan is the one! The best, most versatile broiling pan for travel enthusiasts and RV-owners!

9.1
10 OvenStuff Non-Stick Toaster Oven Bake, Broil and Roast Set
9.0

Versatile and durable, this multi-purpose broiling pan is your go-to option. Forget about burnt food and unevenly cooked meat with this high-quality steel-constructed broiling pan.

9.0

 

1 Editor choice

Frigidaire 5304442087 – Best durable broiler pan

Features

  • Weighs about 2.5 pounds.
  • Black-coloured exterior
  • Measure 15 inches in length
  • Comes with a porcelain layer/coating
  • Two-piece unit, including a top tray and a scrapper

The Frigidaire broiler pan is absolutely impressive with its outstanding and versatile features. First of all, it has a porcelain layering that ensures heat efficiency and therefore, a better user experience. Moreover, the porcelain coating also ensures durability.

Other than that, the black exterior of the pan adds onto its heat efficiency. It will absorb and decrease the loss of heat, keeping the pan hot for a longer period of time.
Furthermore, the pan comes in a two-piece set. A scrapper can be very useful for cleaning and minting the condition of the pan. With its porcelain coating and sturdy built, cleaning will already be an easy job. Many customers noted the good-looking design, along with its lightweight construction.

Some customers reported discoloration after some uses. You should be aware of this issue before purchasing the pan. Discoloration may also occur from lack of maintenance. However, for a low-maintenance option, look further.

Do we recommend this?

This is one of the best broiler pans in the market that you can find. Therefore, we highly recommend this to anyone who wants a multi-purpose, long-lasting broiler pan. This is great for medium to even large amounts of food.

Positives
  • Good looking design
  • Lightweight design makes it convenient to use
  • Porcelain layer for better heating
  • Optimal size for most ovens
  • Durability is high, if maintained properly
Negatives
  • Discoloration issues reported by customers
2

Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan – Best versatile broiler pan

Features

  • 3-in-1 pan with baking, grilling and broiling functionality
  • Built with a carbon steel core
  • Features porcelain covering.
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Weighs about 2.9 pounds.

The Granite War broiling pan gives the best variable performance that broiling pans can give. It makes tough competition to lesser versatile pans that can only be used for one purpose. We have listed this pan as the most versatile one considering its three-in-one functionality. This will save your money, which you would otherwise have to use for buying separate grilling and baking pans. Moreover, it is also lightweight and therefore, convenient to use.

In addition to this, the pan is also layered with non-stick enamel. This ensures that meat does not stick to the grill and cooks perfectly. Plus, it is dishwasher-safe, which makes cleaning and maintenance easier.

The carbon steel core will allow you to cook your food perfectly with little effort. This makes it great for large quantities and gatherings.
With a porcelain layer and a dark-coloured exterior, the pan is guaranteed to have high heat efficiency. Lesser heat will be lost, and more will be absorbed with its dark interior and non-porous construction.

The carbon steel construction is another factor that makes this a great pan for evenly cooking and heating your food. It also ensures a durable and reliable construction.
Do we recommend this?

This broiling pan by Granite Ware has all the right features. With versatile options like grilling and baking, this pan also has an impressive built quality. Therefore, we think that this pan will add great value to your money and experience, and therefore highly recommend it.

Positives
  • Even heat distribution
  • Good looking design
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Has a larger area for cooking
  • High-quality materials
Negatives
  • Porcelain breaks if the pan is used slightly roughly
  • Not suitable for small-sized ovens
3

Disposable Aluminium Foil Broiler Baking Cooking Pan – Best disposable broiler pans

Features

  • Disposable aluminum broiling pan
  • Comes in different bundles of 10, 25, 50, 100, and 200
  • Vertical depth of about 1-5/16 inches
  • Capacity of about 54 ounces
  • Weighs 1.41 pounds

Speaking of easy cleaning and maintenance, this disposable aluminum pan beats everyone. It is a disposable pan made with aluminum foil. With this feature, you do not even have to worry about the cleaning part and just enjoy your food.

Furthermore, if you have larger quantities of food to prepare or will be needing the pan regularly, your problem is solved. This is because it comes in a variety of bundles. You can choose from either 10, 25, 50, 100 or even 2000 pans in a pack. This saves cost and also makes it very convenient.

The disposable nature also further makes it easy to travel with. So, if you want to host a barbeque party in another city or hold a food stall anywhere, these are your best options. The aluminum foil pan only weighs 1.41 pounds. This feature further adds onto its travel-friendliness.

These disposable pans may add onto the trash you throw out. Using them regularly will lead to unnecessary disposal of waste. It is better to use metal/steel pans if you want something for regular and frequent use.

We think that these are especially good for those who intend to travel with a broiling pan, or do not have any arrangements for cleaning the pan. All the same, we suppose the disposable nature of the pans does not make them good for regular home use.

Positives
  • No storage or maintenance issues
  • No need for cleaning
  • Lightweight and travel-friendly
  • Convenient size
  • Various number of pans in a package are available
Negatives
  • Not recommended for long-term home use
4

Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set – Best non-stick broiler pan

Features

  • Comes in a two-piece set, including a drainer
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • 5-year limited warranty
  • Weighs about 12.3 ounces
  • Built with steel

This is our favourite non-stick broiler pan that comes with a non-stick surface that protects your food from overcooking and keeps the pan clean too. The non-stick silver construction makes it stand out from many others in the market. However, that’s not all there is to this pan.

It features a two-piece design. The top is a grill with holes in it that drips all the fat and residue to the container below. This makes the design quite efficient, and also ensures easy clean-ups. To add onto its ease of use and maintenance, it is also safe to be used in a dishwasher. So, say goodbye to scrubbing off the stubborn residue from the pans!

We recommend rinsing the pan with warm water before it is actually put into the dishwasher. This will ensure better cleaning and prevent the build-up of germs.
The limited warranty of 5 years further ensures the reliability of the pan. This makes it good for anyone who wants a reliable pan for long-term use, without having to pay extra for repairs and replacements.

Other than its non-stick surface and lightweight design, it is also designed to meet all your needs. It has extra-wide handles in the corner, which make lifting the pan and handling it a lot easier. This also ensures protection from extra exposure to heat.

Do we recommend this?

Yes, we highly recommend this broiler pan for home use. It is user-friendly, non-stick and also does not put a strain on your pocket.

Positives
  • Lightweight and easy to use
  • Non-stick surface
  • Extra wide handles on the sides
  • Comes with a generous warranty
Negatives
  • Not for larger food quantities
5

General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan and Rack – Best large non-stick broiler pan

Features

  • Venting slits for better performance
  • Has an all-black exterior.
  • Weighs about 0.16 ounces.
  • Can be safely cleaned in a dishwasher
  • Extra-large pan that measures for about 18.2 x 15.7 x 3 inches

Large-sized pans are great for simultaneous cooking. If you are planning on hosting large gatherings or just have a larger number of house members to cook for, then this is the one. With its large cooking area and its black colour, heat-absorbing exterior, this pan will not disappoint.

The most outstanding feature of this pan is its venting slits. The venting slits encourage a better flow of heat and air. This will allow in even distribution of heat. Furthermore, the pan slits also allow extra fat and residue to drip away, making cleaning much easier. The riddance from extra fat also ensures healthier cooking.

There can be an issue with the sharpness of the edges of this pan. This can be very unsafe in gatherings and at home with kids and pets. It can also not safe for the one using the pan inaccurately. So be careful holding it.

If you think that broiler pans are only supposed to be used with ovens, this pan will prove you wrong. This multi-functional and versatile pan can be used in an oven as well as a stove.

Do we recommend this?

We recommend this for regular home use. It has an efficient design and a large area as well. However, it is not recommended for people who want to cook smaller quantities.

Positives
  • Large cooking area
  • Lightweight
  • Even distribution of heat with venting slits
  • Easy to clean in a dishwasher
Negatives
  • No porcelain coating
  • Sharp edges
Features

  • Can be used with up to 1025 degrees of heat
  • Measures 12.75″ by 8.5″ by 1.325″
  • Weighs for about 1 pound
  • All-black exterior
  • Two-piece set, including porcelain broil and bake pan 

The Range Kleen BP106 series is packed with diverse and versatile broiling pans. All the pans in the series have exceptional features, and therefore this model is also one of them. It has a strong, sturdy construction of heavy-duty steel. The surface is covered with porcelain that ensures better heat distribution.

Furthermore, the grills of the pan have slits that allow the fat and oil to drip away. This means you won’t have to cook and eat calorie-rich food. Therefore, with this small-sized pan, you can enjoy healthy food that cooks perfectly.

The pan comes with a high, unexpected price tag. You can find similar quality products from our list at better prices.
The two-piece set is also suitable for various kinds of food that include meat, fish, and vegetables. It can also be great for outdoor use. With its black exterior, heat efficiency will be guaranteed.

Do we recommend this?

Even though it has most of the essential features that you may look for in a pan, the price is relatively high. Therefore, for those on a tight budget, we recommend considering other more affordable options from our list. If price doesn’t matter for you, this reliable brand is exactly what you’re looking for.

Positives
  • Good looking design
  • Good for outdoor use
  • Reliable brand
  • Heavy duty construction with a porcelain coating
Negatives
  • Not for larger quantities
  • A bit pricy
7

Range Kleen Broiler Pan – Best large broiler pan for high temperatures

Features

  • Made with heavy-duty steel
  • The construction is coated with porcelain
  • All-black exterior.
  • Weighs for about 3 pounds
  • Measures 16.5 x 12.5 x 1.6 inches

As you must have noticed already, many of our best broiler pans come from Range Kleen. This is because they have one of the most diverse ranges of products that meet different customer needs. Similarly, this is another broiler pan by Range Kleen that aims to be used for larger quantities of food and for larger gatherings. A good variety of foods and meat can be cooked using this.

First of all, the pan is made with high-quality porcelain-coated steel, ensuring that heat loss is decreased and heat is evenly distributed. Secondly, the pan’s porcelain coating also makes it non-stick.

The pan is useful for all kinds of meat. You can use the pan for cooking fragile meat safely.

Other than its large size and non-stick coating, the pan also lets you cook at high temperatures. You can cook on temperatures as high as 1025 F. With this broiling pan you cook faster and better.

Do we recommend this?

Even though the pan is not the best for small gatherings or quantities of food, we still highly recommend it to all our readers. With its outperforming features, we think it’ll be a great choice.

Positives
  • Large cooking area.
  • Non-stick surface.
  • Porcelain coating.
  • Heavy-duty, durable construction.
Negatives
  • Not recommended for smaller gatherings
8

Norpro 273 Broil/Roast Pan Set – Best broiler pan to cook for two

Features

  • Two-piece set
  • Perforated tray that drains away grease and fat
  • Weighs about 1.43 pounds
  • Dimensions of the pan are 12 x 9 x 1.5 inches
  • The silver-colored pan is built with stainless steel

Norpro has been manufacturing high-quality cookware and kitchen utensils for a long time. Their presence in the market over the years has led them to be one of the most reliable brands, and therefore, this 12-inch pan is one of their bests.

The pan has a sleek, decent looking silver/grey exterior. With its stainless-steel construction, it is bound to last you a long time with minimum maintenance and cleaning responsibilities. The design is also efficient. It allows for grease and fat to drain away, preventing grease building-up for you to clean later.

The pan is neither excessively large nor super small. It’s perfect for people who want to cook single-serving meals or meals for two people. It’s also great for fragile meats and foods of all kinds.
Perhaps, the only drawback we could see with this pan was that it is not recommended to be used in a dishwasher. This means that you’ll be solely responsible for scrubbing and putting in extra effort to clean it.

Do we recommend this?

We recommend this pan for people who want to cook smaller quantities of food. Its small and lightweight design also makes it easy to store, so it’s good for people with limited space in the kitchen.

Positives
  • Small and compact size
  • Good for 2 people
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable construction
Negatives
  • Not suitable for larger food quantities
  • Not dishwasher-safe
9

Nordic Ware 42210 Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler – Best budget broiler pan

Features

  • Two-piece set
  • Can be used in toaster ovens
  • Weighs 9.6 ounces only
  • Non-stick surface
  • Made for traveling and single-serving purposes
  • Cooking surface measures 8.5″L x 6.5″W x 0.63″H

We did not want people with busy routines, who want to cook easy and healthy, to feel left out. So, we have added this travel-friendly, single-serving broiling pan.
The pan is beige-colored with a black grill that allows grease and oil to drain away. This will ensure that you do not eat meat rich in calories, and your busy schedule is balanced with health and energy as well.

Furthermore, the pan weighs only a few ounces, which makes it easy to carry, easy to store, and easy to travel with. With its sleek design and lightweight construction, it also ensures a non-stick surface for the perfectly cooked meat.

It’s strongly constructed, compelling the pan to last you a long time. It also features a black metal rack/grill, which is not permanent. You can remove or place the grill as per your requirement.

Do we recommend this?

We strongly recommend this pan to students and corporate workers with a busy life. It is very affordable as well, compared to other pans from our list. It is easy to store and equally easy to use.

Positives
  • Affordable
  • Lightweight
  • Sleek design
  • Great for single servings
  • Removable metal rack
Negatives
  • Not for families
Features

  • Two-piece set
  • Features an 8.5 inches by 6.5-inch bake pan, roast pan and a broiling pan.
  • Made with heavy-duty steel
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • The DuraGlide Plus coating makes it non-stick
  • Wide edges for easy handling

When you are looking for the best broiler pan for personal-sized cooking, make sure that it has all the features that make it easy to use. Therefore, we have added this small-sized broiler pan in our list. It is one of the best you will find in the market, considering that it is safe to be used in a dishwasher, has heavy-duty construction, and is perfect for single servings.

The pan is great for students who live alone or have to cook food for one. It is also great for people trying to cut down and eat healthily. Since it has big holes to extract fat and oil and is also small, it’s perfect for a one-person meal.

With a lightweight yet sturdy built, this pan is easy to use and store. It has wide edges for easy handling, while also protecting from contact with heat.
Other than that, it is a completely non-stick pan, which means it will be very easy to clean!

This is an American-made pan, and the manufacturers claim it to be made with the highest quality steel. The high quality construction will ensure evenly distributed heat.

Do we recommend this?

We definitely recommend this Range Kleen broiling pan to people who won’t be using it frequently or only need it for one-person serving. It is also a good choice for people who have a tight budget but want a durable, efficiently-designed pan. This is also multi-functional, so it will add great value to your money.

Positives
  • Affordable
  • Holes for draining fat
  • Multi-functional
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Easy to handle and use
Negatives
  • Not for large quantities
  • No warranty
,

Buyer’s Guide

What to get the best cooking experience from a new broiler pan?

Go on reading and you will find out all the necessary criteria, which help you to opt for the best model.

Now that you’ve looked at ten best broiler pans, you must also know that there are other things that need to be taken into consideration. Broiler pans are essential, but you cannot invest and purchase a new one easily every now and then. Therefore, make this one-time decision wisely by making a thorough decision.

This section will help you in deciding whether you truly need a broiler pan. It will also list the most important aspects and factors to consider when buying a broiler pan.

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food-3

Benefits of having a good quality broiler pan at home

Investing in a broiler pan that costs about $25-30 for one-time use is not a good option. In such cases, you should instead borrow or rent it from someone. However, broiler pans like the Handi-Foil pans are a better option. They come in a pack of 50 and more and are disposable, which means you don’t have to clean them or worry about ruining it. This also makes it easy to store. Therefore, we highly recommend you always to decide whether you truly need to own a broiler pan or you just need it for one-time use. If you are not sure, here are some uses and advantages of owning a broiler pan at home:

Healthier food preparation

The best part about cooking on a broiler pan is that it reduces the fat in your food. Unlike other pans, these pans make the fat of the meat drip down from the grills. This prevents the meat from absorbing back the fat. Therefore, the meat is healthier and lesser in calories.

Other than this, you also will need less or no oil at all. You barely need to brush the grills/grate with a minimum amount of oil to cook your meat properly.

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food-2

Lesser cooking time

The most important purpose of the broiler pan is that it lets you cook at high flame. The heat from the high flame is guaranteed to be distributed evenly throughout the meat, which cooks it quickly, reducing the cooking time and also saving energy costs. Also, you do not have to worry about unevenly cooked sides of the meat. This is because the broiler pan can have a lid to cover cook meat from both sides simultaneously. So, lesser time and lesser efforts are required to cook your food perfectly!

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food-6

Great for delicate meat

Since there is barely any flipping required, delicate meat is safe with broiler pans. In fact, they are the best for delicate meat.

Aspects to consider before buying the best broiler pan

Here’s a list of all the important factors that need consideration before the final purchase:

Maintenance and cleaning

Broiler pans usually need lots of regular cleaning since meat fat, oil and other greasy residue come into contact with them. Therefore, it is very important to make sure that the broiler pan you have chosen to buy has easy means of cleaning. It should be big enough for you to scrub properly. And the material it is made with should be non-stick so that the grease comes off easily.

Everyone tends to keep cleaning at bay since it is not the most comfortable task of the day. So, we highly recommend checking the cleaning procedure and ease of the pan you are going to buy. By checking the construction material and user reviews, you can get an idea about how easy it is to clean the pan.

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food

Built quality

Your broiler pan should last you a long time. It should not be flimsy and break only after a few uses. Moreover, the pan should also be made with such good material that it does not leave behind a smell in your food or the environment.

The best kind of pans that we would recommend is non-stick. Other than that, carbon steel construction also ensures even distribution of heat and a good built as well.

To ensure corrosion and rust free broiler pans, you can also go for products that are coated with porcelain. Porcelain withstands exposure to all kinds of substances, including acid while maintaining the pan’s appearance.

Size and capacity

The dimensions of the broiler grill and its weight are another very important factor. The capacity of the grill refers to the amount of food it can hold at once. The ideal size of the pan you need will hugely depend on how you plan on using it.

For example, if you plan to use the pan for larger BBQ parties with several people, then you might need a large broiler pan such as the General Electric WB48X10056.
However, without examining and considering the size of it against its usage, you might get a pan that is used up to its full potential. For example, if you buy a larger pan even when you have to cook food for 2 people, the cooking time will increase, it will consume more energy, and will be difficult to store as well.

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food-4

Eco-friendliness

Many broiler pans are now available in the market that have more eco-friendly features. There are some pans that are constructed with harmful materials that emit chemicals and gases that may get into your food. Therefore, make sure that the broiler pan you buy is eco-friendly. PTFE and PFOA free pans such as the Granite Ware Bake are good options to ensure safe eating and cooking.

Colour

Other than the basic appearance and size of the pan, you should also consider its colour. The colour of the pan plays an important role in heat generation and absorption. Also, many people say that darker-coloured pans absorb more heat, resulting in energy efficiency. Therefore, go for black or dark-toned pans for better performance and energy-saving too.

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food-7

Versatility

By versatility, we are referring to the range of features that the broiler pan has to offer and how functional they are. The more multi-purpose the pan is, the better it will be. That way, you can use it on more than just one occasion and for more than one purpose.

For example, there are pans available in the market that also have a shelf/storage space attached to it; you can keep your cooking essentials like a spatula, salt shaker and other lightweight objects there.

Furthermore, you should also see that the pan does not restrict you to using it only for some particular meat/food. For example, the Granit Ware pan from our list can be used for baking, grilling, and broiling too. This makes it perfect for more than one use, saving you extra cost for a griller and an oven for baking.

Weight and storage

The weight of the broiler pan is another important consideration as that will determine the ease of use and portability. As mentioned earlier, a broiler pan should be multi-functional. Therefore a lightweight yet sturdy pan is important for multi-functionality. This is because due to its lightweight, you can carry it to places with you in a car or a truck.

Moreover, a lightweight pan will also be much easier to store. Remember, getting a small pan when you need a larger space will waste your money. However, you can make sure that even with a large size, it still has a lightweight construction. This way, you’ll also be able to store it without much hassle.

10 Best Broiler Pan for Delicious Grilled Food-8

Conclusion

Now you are fully equipped with the relevant information for buying the best broiling pan. Always remember to consider the most important aspects mentioned earlier. These include the size of the pan, your usage, construction quality, and portability. By shortlisting the 10 best broiler pans from the market, we hope to have helped you in picking one for yourself!

We think that the Frigidaire 5304442087 pan might be the answer to almost everyone’s search. It has all the essential to extra features that you may need when cooking. It is also multi-purpose, and also has high-quality construction for even heat distribution.

You have read the article! Great job! Do not forget to rate the article.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Pick Advisor