Are you a fan of smoking meats but you hate charcoal or can’t afford a pellet grill? Well, the best smoker box for a gas grill will be your best friend then!
A smoker box is essentially a container made of metal that’s used to provide a smoky flavor to cooked or grilled meats. Some people love that smoky aroma of meats, and while it isn’t for everyone, it’s a great option.
Smoker boxes fit right on a gas grill, but they’re a little different than your average charcoal tray as you might assume. With gas grills, you can usually use wood chips, but you can also use a pellet version as well. Some smoker boxes for gas grills come in different shapes and sizes, and that’s why it’s important to look into what you want from a smoker box for a gas grill and choose the one that works for you.
All of these boxes do essentially the same job. You simply put wood chips or pellets you want to use in there, then place a box underneath the grill grates, and let it work its magic. They’re relatively inexpensive and tend to last much longer than smoker pellets do.
Before you choose one, you’ll want to make sure that the bottom of the grates and the burner shields have enough clearance. If you’re really stumped, do research on your grill and see for yourself which smoker box is the best option for you.
Smoking meats is like adding spice, and they can provide a wonderful, flavorful texture to your meats. This post will highlight the best smoker box for a gas grill that you can buy, and why you should consider each one.
Our Top 10 Best Smoker Boxes For Gas Grill
If you are looking for a quick answer, then check out our product table. Here, we’ll highlight the best models, and why each one might fit you, including price points or other valuable information.
- 25% thicker than previous models
- Stainless steel
- Has full warranty
- Uses wood pellet chips
- Free cooking journal app included with purchase
The first on our list is one by Cave Tools. This smoker box is now thicker than ever before, and it’s strong enough it won’t warp when placed under heat.
It’s very easy to use, and you can add more chips while grilling meats. It’s a pretty large box already, and it fits perfectly on a grill right next to a flavorizer. This smoker box also comes with recipes for you to try too, so if you’re new to this, you’ll definitely want that. It’s the perfect beginner’s smoker box, since you can learn how to use it, and overall customers are satisfied with this smoker box.
The stainless steel box does smolder the chips instead of fully burn them, which will help prevent fires, making it one of the safest smoker boxes on the market.
There are over 40,000 happy customers, and for the most part, using this box is pretty easy. As a word of caution, you should always soak the chips before you use this one, despite what the instructions say, as users have found it can sometimes have trouble getting hot enough to smoke your food.
- Very easy to use
- Can load lots of chips
- Has free recipes for you to use
- Customer service offers a full warranty
- Thick so it won’t burn or catch fire in the grill
- Even though the guide doesn’t say it, you will need to smoke the chips
- Sometimes has trouble getting hot enough to fully smoke the meat
- Up to 5 hours of smoking
- Hexagonal shape
- Made with stainless steel
- Uses wood pellets
- Weighs 16 ounces
- Can be used with electric, charcoal, and gas grills
This is a great smoker that’s versatile. It works for literally any grill, so if you decide to ever get a charcoal grill in the future, you can still use this. It can produce lots of smoke for your next barbecue. This one doesn’t use wood chips, instead, it’s made for wood pellets, such as cherry, apple, pecan, and others. This is a great smoker because you can diffuse the smoke quite readily, which gives you a better result from the grilling process than other models do. This stays in a singular place, providing a balanced smoking experience. It is made from stainless steel, so it’ll last longer, won’t catch on fire, and is incredibly easy to clean.
This one is good if you’re looking for a versatile smoker that can be used, and it’s pretty small, so it fits anywhere. Users do say however, you’ll need to use this for about 4-5 hours to get real flavor.
- Super versatile and fits any grill type
- The different wood pellets offer much more flavor than other smokers
- Fits perfectly into any small grills
- It offers a long period of smoking
- Lightweight and portable, so you don’t have to worry about it being too heavy
- Comes with a free eBook with recipes
- Small, so it can’t hold too many pellets
- Only gives some flavor if used for several hours
- Made from cast iron
- About 3.6 pounds
- Holds about 2 cups of chips
- Has a vented opening to control the amount of smoke
- Works with most of the grills
- 5×8 inches
Char-broil is a company that’s been around for over 70 years, and it makes products that are built to last. This cast-iron box will never warp as the material is capable of withstanding extremely high temperatures.
The smoker box is vented so you can put it next to your food right on the grate, it’ll smoke give enough smoke to enhance the flavor. It works with most grills, including gas, electric, and charcoal grills.
This box offers a unique smoking experience. It is sturdy, but users do recommend to keep it from getting wet because this can rust. You should coat the box with oil before you heat it, so you don’t have to worry about rusting.
If you want a cheap smoker that you can buy once and for all, this is a great one to consider.
- Small and gets the job done
- Affordable compared to other smokers
- Has a vented opening to control the food
- Right amount of pellets
- Durable as long as you oil it
- Some users report the handle comes broken
- Some people notice the item rusts very fast if you don’t oil it properly
- Can become brittle over time if you don’t clean it
- Unique V-shaped design
- Stainless steel
- Hinged lid
- Ashes kept in the box
- About 13.25 inches long
- Vented opening for smoke to release
If you want a unique smoker, then look no further. This one comes with a unique V-shape which means it fits perfectly between your deflector bars, offering a very intense and smoky flavor.
It is made of stainless steel, so it won’t break down no matter how hot it gets. The grill comes with a hinged lid so you can put your wood chips in it. Many users appreciate that it’s very easy to insert the chips. The ashes stay within the box, so once you’re done, you just take it out and clean it. It’s small but effective, and although it’s a different shape compared to the rest, it gets the job done.
This one is recommended for those who want something that fits perfectly in their grill, and also something that’s affordable.
- Small and effective
- Keeps all the wood chips in one place
- Great for indirect cooking overheat
- Relatively big, so holds a lot of chips
- Worked with both soaked and unsoaked chips
- Very easy to clean
- Sometimes if improperly inserted the wood will catch fire
- You can’t adjust the ventilation on this, so it may not cook your food right
- Stainless steel
- Hinged lid to put chips in
- Wavy design for ventilation
- Controlled venting to properly smoke meats
- W-shaped bottom design
- Wavy smoke outlet
This smoking box comes with a wavy design to offer a unique cooking experience. It comes made of stainless steel and with a hinged frame for easy insertion of chips. It’s quite dense and offers a much larger area of smoked food.
The W-shape let it sit directly on the flame deflector under the grate, so if you want an intense smoky flavor, you can place meat right over it. However, you can also place it on the grates as well. It offers a much more versatile experience.
Additionally, you can smoke without having to spend extra time cleaning the grill afterwards as it holds ashes inside.
One thing to note, however, is that some users report it works better on the grill, rather than over it. Also, you should have a squirt bottle on hand too for the chips to get the proper smoking experience.
- Fits almost all kinds of grills
- Can be put over the flavorizer bar for an intense smoking experience
- Can withstand high temperatures
- Very high levels of thermal conductivity
- The wavy design offers an intense smoky flavor to all your food
- Some users report it doesn’t fit their grills well
- You have to be mindful of this one because you might have to coat the chips more often
- The results might be too smoky for some people
- Thick stainless steel design
- Hinged top for opening
- Weighs 1 pound
- Dimensions: 8.8 inches x 1.8 inches
- Ventilated holes for smoke
This grill box is simple, but it turns your gas grill into a powerful smoking machine. It’s very simple to use, you literally just throw the chips in, and put it over the flame. This one, however, is different because it’s made with a very strong stainless steel.
Many other smoker boxes tend to warp after a bit, but this one is made with reinforced stainless steel, so it won’t be breaking down anytime soon.
This also offers a very easy hinge to open up, so you literally just pop the top off, throw chips in, and then continue smoking (but please use grilling mitts while doing that). It is incredibly large, so you don’t have to refill as much, and with a full money-back warranty, you can guarantee this smoker box is here to help
This one is recommended for those with larger grills, who have space to smoke more foods with it.
- Incredibly strong so won’t warp
- Easy to open and close
- Smokes pretty quickly
- Works for every grill
- Wonderful aroma is attained quickly with holes on the sides of a box
- While it heats fast, the smoke dies down quickly
- Might take a few tries to fully master
- Box can get charred in super high heat
- Up to 12 hours of smoking
- Weighs 12 ounces
- Stainless steel
- Pellet smoker
- Full smoke smoker box
This is one of the more expensive ones on our list, but if you want a full smoke experience, this is a great one. It is a maze pellet smoker, which means that you can put the chips in, and let them smoke, and since it has a maze design, all of the smoke will come out through the ventilation, hitting your food.
Unlike some of the others on our lists, this one lasts a much longer time and is perfect for pretty much anything that you might want smoked. It’s rust-free, which means that you don’t have to worry about it corroding or breaking down. It’s incredibly lightweight and fits on practically any grill
This one offers a lot of freedom and convenience, but it doesn’t seem to last as long as the claims that are made about it state. However, you’ll still get a large amount of smoke over a long period of time. Some users also don’t like the absence of a lid. Bur this feature allows to smoke large portions faster and the box produces plenty of smoke.
- Offers an extra smoky experience
- The maze design lets it burn for a lot longer than most smokers
- It won’t corrode over time
- Lightweight and small enough for any grill
- You have to only use pellets, and make sure they’re properly tucked in
- Some people can’t get it to smoke for long enough
- Hot and cold smoking
- 6” tube to insert into your grill
- Ventilation on all four sides
- 5 ounces
- Smokes for up to 2 hours
This is a smoker tube that useful for cold smoking technology, which means that when you use it for smoking cheese, it offers a really deep flavor. This is also a type of smoking that’s used in food preservation, so it’s recommended you get this one if you’re looking to do this type of smoking.
The tube gives up to 2 hours of cold smoke, but if you add pellets every hour or so this works with maximum efficiency.
It’s incredibly clean, and the round design makes it very easy to put into your smoker. It is used for both hot and cold smoke, so if you do choose to heat this up, it won’t break down. It is also made with stainless steel and it’s resistant to corrosion. It’s incredibly portable, so it can be used in pretty much any location.
- Versatile for hot and cold smoking experiences
- Small and incredibly portable
- Easy to fill up
- Smokes anything pretty easily
- Stainless steel so it avoids corrosion
- Creates a clean smoke
- May not smoke efficiently for the full 2 hours if you don’t add pellets
- Some users report the food isn’t incredibly smoky
- Two chambers for chips
- Stainless steel construction
- Control for ventilation
- Thick handles
- Includes an air damper hinged lid
This is a smoker accessory that’s a little different from the rest. The box sits on top of your grids for cooking, so it will pull the heat downwards and smoke it faster. This one is very thin and comes with a hinged lid.
It’s a premium item that offers a deep, smoky flavor. The sliding lid allows for an adjustable smoke output, and the handles make it easier to move so you don’t accidentally burn yourself.
This model is best used with wood chips and liquids, and you can experiment with this. It does come with two chambers to offer twice the power of smoking, and you can also damper one side of this too. This one is a little bit pricier than the others, but it is a professional-grade smoking box.
This one is recommended for those who want a premium smoking experience. But, some users report it can be hard to open up the box to add more chips, which does create a safety hazard.
- Offers a versatile smoking experience
- The two chambers let you add more flavoring in
- You can control how much smoke gets on your food
- Heavy duty
- Is hard to open when heated up
- Some users report cracks in the metal after a use
- Vent slider sometimes breaks down quickly
- Stainless steel
- Hinged lid for inserting chips
- Weighs 1 pound
- Fits most Weber grills
- Dimensions: 9.7 x 4.7 inches
This stainless steel smoker box offers a variety of smoky flavors and a unique design. It’s very easy to open so you won’t have problems adding the chips.
This is a universal smoker, and it fits most grills out there quite easily. It is a little smaller than the rest on the list, but it does the job pretty well. The box is made to be placed on top of grates and you can easily add hickory, oak, apple, or cherry wood chips in it. Plus, it works with both gas and charcoal grills.
It fits both large and small grills easily, so you don’t have to worry about it possibly being too snug for your grill. It does a decent job, but some users say be careful, because it sometimes does catch on fire quite quickly, so make sure never to leave this unattended.
- Good basic smoker box that fits most grills
- Simple to add chips to
- Can add smoky flavor to any foods
- Stainless steel, so won’t warp as easily
- Users report this box catches on fire at low temperatures
- Can sometimes warp over time
- You always need to soak the chips before using the box
There are a few considerations you should keep in mind when choosing a gas grill, and we’ll highlight each of these important features below.
Materials and Design
The materials and the design of your smoker box do determine what type of smoking experience you get. Do you want something that offers your average smoking experience? Or do you want something that gets a deep, really penetrative smoking experience?
Almost all of these are made with stainless steel, but the Char-boil Smoker Box is the only one that isn’t, it’s made with cast iron. That means, it’s recommended that you oil this one up before you use it, so you’re not corroding the material. The Grillaholics is also made with a very heavy-duty stainless steel, so it’s the only one on the list you don’t have to worry about catching on fire, or worse.
In terms of generic shape, most boxes are in the shape of a rectangle. However, some, like the Charcoal Companion Smoker box, are made with a unique V-shape to it, making it very easy to put in your smoker.
The weight amongst most of these is generally around a pound, but some, like the A-MAZE N AMNTS6 is very small since it is a portable smoker. In general, this doesn’t have much bearing on the product itself, but some people do like to have something that’s small and easy to put together.
In general, the Grillaholics is probably your heaviest smoker, since it weighs around a pound or so, but most of them are very easy to put into your grill, so it isn’t much you have to worry about.
Types of Chips it holds
For some people, the type of chips it holds does matter. Wood chips are usually your way to go, and the Cave Tools Smoker Box is your best one for that since it holds a lot of chips. The Grillholics is another good one because it holds a decent amount of chips, so you don’t have to worry about refilling.
You may also want to consider the pellets too. The LIZZQ Premium uses the pellets instead of the chips, offering a different smoking experience.
All of these chips come in a variety of flavors: apple, hickory, or whatever. You can go to the store and get your chips to insert into this, and get some other flavors too.
Some of them, like the Broil King 60190 Premium, offer a two-chamber system, which means you can put two different types of chips in each to smoke a variety of meats. Whatever type of flavoring you get, you should consider this factor when choosing your smoker.
The lid on most of these is a hinged lid, which means that you need to pull the top off, put the chips in, and close this. Most of the time this works well, but as a safety precaution, do understand that the lids are hot too, so always have heat-proof gloves to handle the smoker box.
Some users report that the Weber 7576 Universal Stainless smoker box is better used without a lid since it tends to catch on fire if you have the lid on there. When you cook at higher temperatures, some of these smoker boxes are hard to work with, so make sure that you get one with a lid that’s easy to remove, and practice removing it. Also, never handle these barehanded.
Ease of Cleaning
Most of the boxes we reviewed are pretty easy to clean. When you get one, you simply take the chips out, clean out the ashes, and wipe it down. Make sure to fully dry this so it doesn’t corrode or rust. None of these are super complex to clean, but you might have some trouble with the Weber 7576 since it tends to hinge closed, and it can get stuck. You also want to check the box after you’re done cooking to make sure that the box isn’t deformed in any way.
How it Fits within a grill
Since most of these are small, they fit within a grill quite easily. But, some of them like the Broil King 60190 Premium actually sit on top of the grill, and you put the food on top. Others will sit near the flavorizer bars, such as in the case with the Cave Tools Smoker Box for BBQ. Usually, they are pretty easy to insert, and once you finished putting it there, you should make sure it’s not over any hot burners, or else it may catch on fire.
This should come as an obvious thing but NEVER leave these unattended. Anything involving fire shouldn’t occur, but some of these tend to catch on fire at higher temperatures. The Grillaholics smoker box usually doesn’t.
You should always check this, and if you do notice it catch fire, get some chips on top of it, or extinguish it.
How Fast the Smoke Comes out
Some of these have a very fast flame, such as the Skyflame Wood Chip smoker box, and while it’s fast, it tends to last only a bit. Others like the A-Maze-N AMNPS last longer since it is a maze smoker. You can decide for yourself how long you tend to use this on average, and how long you want to go without re-adding chips. Those that last a little longer reduce your time spent adding chips, which also reduces any hazards associated with burning.
A couple of these, like the Cave Tools Smoker Box, offers a free guide on how to smoke foods. That’s a handy little addition, and worth considering when choosing a smoker box.
You might have to screw the hinges to the lid, but otherwise no.
Usually, anywhere from 100-250 degrees. But, some users report that even at 85 degrees some boxes burn.
It’s not recommended, especially if the hinge is warped. The wrapped box can catch on fire and damage your grill.
First, don’t panic, second, use chips to put out the fire. If that doesn’t work, extinguish the smoker box fire.
Get one that fits your grill, so find out the dimensions of a box and compare them to the size of your grill. It’s even better if the box comes from the same manufacturer!
Smoker boxes are incredibly useful for smoking meats, as it takes out the extra step of using tinfoil to get the job done. The best smoker box for gas grills on our list is, of course, the Cave Tools Smoker Box for BBQ, since it is a great, big smoker box that you can use to get a wealth of wonderful tastes for your meats. It also comes with a full warranty, and other freebies, so it’s the most beginner-friendly of the models we have here.
But regardless of what you choose, these all provide a unique, and fun smoking experience that you’ll enjoy, and you can smoke a variety of wonderful foods, meats, and even fruit with these handy boxes.